Igniting Change in Education

BrightMinds Bulletin

Author

Jessica Maddry
November 11, 2024

BrightMinds Bulletin: Research & News on AI in Education

At BrightMinds, we are committed to reshaping education by amplifying the voices that truly matter in K-12 settings. In this edition, we explore the transformative power of centering students, educators, and families in education, creating a pathway for real change that aligns with the core values of BrightMinds. By giving voice to those at the heart of education, we aim to foster learning environments that are safe, inclusive, and empowering.

Igniting Real Change in Education

Moving Beyond Surface-Level Changes It’s easy to see new tech tools in classrooms and think education is improving, but are these tools truly student-centered? Often, these tools simplify and reinforce traditional systems rather than changing them. At BrightMinds, we believe in creating authentic transformation by amplifying voices that call for safe, meaningful educational experiences.

The Impact of Technology-Driven Classrooms Too often, best practices are influenced by those outside the classroom, focusing on data and profits over genuine student engagement. While these initiatives claim to “personalize” learning, they often result in standardized, one-size-fits-all approaches. True transformation begins with elevating student agency, addressing safety, and empowering teachers.

Rethinking AI as a Catalyst for Equity AI has the potential to drive inclusive, personalized education, but only if approached responsibly. We must be cautious of the risks of data misuse, biased algorithms, and privacy concerns. With the right approach, AI can be a powerful tool to uplift diverse voices in education, fostering equity rather than reinforcing existing divides.

AI: A Potential Catalyst

Artificial intelligence offers an opportunity to reimagine educational systems, but we must proceed thoughtfully. AI could serve as a powerful catalyst to reshape how we approach student-centered learning- if we ensure it’s used responsibly. With the right focus, AI can support equity and truly personalized education. But if implemented without care, it risks accelerating the same issues that have hampered progress, amplifying inequities and embedding biases faster than ever.

Pathways Forward: Prioritizing Authentic Change

Recent research shows us the power of centering education around those it serves:

  • Elevating Student Voices: When students have a say in their learning, their engagement, well-being, and performance improve significantly.

  • Ensuring Privacy and Safety: As technology expands its role in education, safeguarding student privacy and enforcing ethical use of data becomes crucial.

  • Reducing Testing Overload: Research demonstrates that while standardized tests provide some insights, over-dependence can stifle creativity and critical thinking, limiting students’ holistic growth.

The Financial Reality of EdTech

As the role of technology in education expands, the costs associated with EdTech continue to rise. Schools and districts around the world are investing heavily in infrastructure, devices, software, and digital curriculum materials. According to the latest reports, U.S. K-12 schools spent approximately $35.8 billion on EdTech in 2022, including investments in digital learning tools, cybersecurity, and data management platforms. This figure is expected to grow significantly, with global EdTech spending predicted to reach over $404 billion by 2025.

Key Areas of EdTech Expenditure

  1. Digital Devices and Infrastructure
    One-time expenses for devices, such as laptops, tablets, and interactive whiteboards, are coupled with ongoing costs for maintenance, updates, and tech support.

  2. Software Subscriptions and Licensing
    With an increasing reliance on subscription-based software, schools face a steady increase in annual expenditures. This trend is predicted to continue as AI-driven platforms require more frequent updates and integration.

  3. Cybersecurity and Data Management
    As student data privacy becomes a greater concern, schools need improved cybersecurity measures. Future costs in this area are anticipated to surge, as districts are forecasted to spend an estimated 40% more on cybersecurity over the next five years.

  4. Training and Professional Development
    Teacher training in digital tools, data analysis, and cybersecurity is now essential for the effective implementation and ethical use of technology. Current spending on professional development for EdTech in U.S. schools is estimated to be around $3.4 billion annually and is expected to grow.

How Technology Requirements Amplify Inequity for Students

The rising cost of educational technology creates challenges, particularly for students who lack access to the necessary tools. For instance, imagine a young student who is assigned digital homework but is too young to be issued a school-provided device. If their family cannot afford reliable internet or an additional device at home, the student faces significant obstacles in completing assignments. This can result in missed learning opportunities, lower engagement with coursework, and a widening academic gap compared to peers who have ready access to technology.

The implications of such disparities become more pronounced as educational technology becomes further integrated into everyday learning. Students without reliable access may fall behind, not only academically but also in digital literacy skills crucial for future learning and career opportunities. These inequities emphasize the importance of affordable, accessible edtech solutions and policies that address connectivity gaps—especially in underserved communities.

Future Outlook and Considerations

As EdTech continues to evolve with AI and adaptive learning, its costs will remain significant. While it promises personalization and improved outcomes, the financial burden on districts is substantial.

EdTech companies may offer flexible payment models, but the long-term sustainability of these costs is questionable. To maximize ROI, schools must prioritize adaptable, inclusive, and effective solutions. A strategic approach to EdTech spending is essential to balance financial commitments with educational goals and ensure equitable outcomes.

BrightMinds' Mission: Amplifying Guiding Voices

At BrightMinds, we are committed to:

  • Advocating for safe, student-centered tech that prioritize students' needs

  • Using AI responsibly to empower students rather than exploit them

  • Creating educational environments that focus on the true purpose of learning1

By amplifying the voices of students, educators, and families, we can build a future where students are heard, safe, and empowered in schools that truly serve them. This critical moment in K-12 education calls for meaningful transformations that go beyond surface-level changes, igniting conversations that truly matter and reshaping education to align with the needs of those it impacts most.

We'd Love to Hear from You!

Have a question about AI in education? Or maybe there's a topic you'd like us to cover in a future newsletter? We're here to help! Send us your questions, and we'll feature them in our next edition.

Thanks for being part of our community!

Informed choices. Safer Schools.Stronger Communities.

Resources: 

K-12 Education Technology : Sector Brief - March 27, 2024 https://www.harriswilliams.com/our-insights/k-12-education-technology-q1-2024

How the rapid adoption of edtech is changing K-12 education: https://www.ey.com/en_us/insights/education/the-rapid-adoption-of-edtech-is-changing-k-12